How to Develop a Thesis for a Movie Comparison Paper

By Mason Howard ; Updated September 15, 2017
Film study promotes critical inquiry.

The study of film is a viable and interesting approach to gaining insights into the workings of contemporary culture and the effects of media. Writing a paper comparing two movies allows the writer to analyze and highlight the similarities and differences between the two. To begin any scholarly investigation and film comparison, the writer must begin with a statement that precludes the argument to be laid out in the paper. This is known as thesis statement.

Brainstorm the themes, technical approaches, patterns and important issues you see coming up in the films. It is a good idea to watch the films more than once, as connections will be more likely to reveal themselves after several viewings.

Come up with a broad, general topic from your brainstorm that you think is intellectually interesting, challenging and can lead to an argument substantial enough to meet the length requirement of the paper. General topics for films might include “violence,” “the role of women,” “mise-en-scene,” or “history.” Make sure that elements of the theme can be found in both films.

Ask a question based on the topic to help narrow it down. For example if you are interested in the role of women, you might ask, “Why are women in the two films objectified?” If you are interested in mise-en-scene, you might ask, “What do props, sets and elements of design say about the psychology of the characters?” If you are interested in violence, you might ask, “Why does one director show excessive violence and not the other?”

Answer the question to create your thesis. For example, “Props, sets and elements of design in (film titles here) show that the characters are burdened and troubled by social inequalities." An effective thesis statement is able to be argued for and against.

About the Author

Mason Howard is an artist and writer in Minneapolis. Howard's work has been published in the "Creative Quarterly Journal of Art & Design" and "New American Paintings." He has also written for art exhibition catalogs and publications. Howard's recent writing includes covering popular culture, home improvement, cooking, health and fitness. He received his Master of Fine Arts from the University of Minnesota.